My Nanny made the best mushroom barley soup. Her recipe was her mother’s, my Grandma Anna’s, who was known to be a great cook, and while I knew my Grandma Anna for many years, she was well beyond her cooking phase by the time I was born, so I grew up with fantasies of my great-grandmother’s soup and the pleasure of my grandmother’s soup.
This soup was at every family event. Jewish holidays, American holidays, birthdays, weekend visits, winter vacations. I knew that whenever I showed up, there would be fresh, hearty, delicious soup waiting just for me. So, one college vacation, when both I would be at home and my Nanny would be visiting, I organized a lock-down. We were going to write down this recipe, once and for all, a recipe replete with handfuls of salt, water up the big chip in the enamel pot, meat products that you had to special order from the butcher, herbs tied with white string that only got added at the end of cooking. I had images that as my Nanny prepared the soup, I would have her pause so I could measure and quantify and record. And then we were side by side in the kitchen. She pulled out her cooking utensils, her fresh herbs and vegetables. However, she couldn’t quite remember whether it was a turnip or a parsnip that got added. I am grateful for this mystery, though, because the last item she pulled out was a package of Maneschewitz Mushroom Barley soup mix! Seems this soup, a core of my family’s meals, a soup that wafted immigrant and tradition and connection and cooking-all-day-on-the-back-of-the-stove richness, didn’t have as much mystery to it as I had endowed it all these years. And yet, it is still “The Soup”. Mention it to my brother or my cousins, and they will wistfully think back to eating that soup. I have yet to share the recipe, which I did write down, with my cousin. I can’t even eat the soup anymore because of allergies. And yet, it will live on. My children know that I grew up on this soup, and for them, it is part of our family history. When they move into their own homes, this recipe will be gifted to them. Because even if you start with a package of soup, needing to talk to the butcher to get ingredients, wrapping white string around herbs that only get added at the end of cooking, and asking everyone you know what the difference is between a turnip and a parsnip makes a soup that is anything but common.
This post was submitted by dherman.